What did people think about the world before anyone had a microscope, an equation or a laboratory?
They had the same things we have: their eyes, their ears, the sky above them and the river in front of them. And they asked the same question we still ask: What is everything really made of?
Their answers were not measured. But they were carefully thought through, and they were written down. Some of them resemble questions that physics still has not settled. Is that a coincidence?
In India: "That thou art"
In the Upanishads, among the oldest philosophical texts of India, a father explains to his son how everything fits together as a whole. He asks him to dissolve salt in water. The salt disappears from sight, but it is there in every single drop. Then the father says:
"Tat tvam asi" — That thou art. (Chāndogya Upanishad 6.13.1–3)
If the salt is in every drop without our seeing it, how much else is present without our seeing it?
In China: the way that cannot be spoken
The Daodejing, which tradition attributes to Laozi, opens with a sentence that has been interpreted and debated for more than two thousand years:
"The way that can be spoken of / Is not the constant way." (Daodejing, chapter 1)
What does it mean that the most important thing cannot be put into words? Is that a weakness of thought, or a limit of words?
The Buddha: nothing stands alone
A central idea in the Buddha's teaching is that whatever arises, arises in dependence on something else. Nothing has a core that stands on its own. According to the texts, these were his last words:
"Conditions fall apart. Persist with diligence." (Mahāparinibbāna Sutta, Dīgha Nikāya 16, section 6.7)
If nothing stands alone, what then is a "thing"?
Miletus: the boundless
In the sixth century BCE, Anaximander of Miletus, a Greek city on the coast of present-day Turkey, asked what the world is made of. His teacher, Thales, had answered water. Anaximander answered apeiron
: the boundless, the indefinite. From it everything arises, and to it everything returns.
Why did he choose something without form, rather than something you could touch?
The Pythagoreans: the world as music
Pythagoras himself wrote nothing that has survived. What we know comes from others. Aristotle tells us that the so-called Pythagoreans regarded "the whole heaven" as a musical scale and a number (Metaphysics 986a). Later sources tell us that the Pythagoreans discovered that strings with simple length ratios such as 2 : 1, 3 : 2 and 4 : 3 give the tones the ear perceives as pure. The ratios already appear in the work of the Pythagorean Philolaus.
Is it a coincidence that our ear perceives simple ratios as harmony?
Heraclitus: the river
Heraclitus of Ephesus is known for the sentence that you cannot step into the same river twice. But that sentence is a later paraphrase. The fragment that is considered genuine says something else:
On those who step into the same rivers, ever new waters flow. (Heraclitus, fragment B12, freely translated)
The river is the same, but the water is always new. What, then, is "the river"? Is it the water, or the pattern the water follows?
Heraclitus also held that harmony arises from opposites. Aristotle reports his view like this: from what differs comes the most beautiful harmony (Nicomachean Ethics 1155b, fragment B8). He compared it to the bow and the lyre (fragment B51)
: the tension between opposing forces holds the bow and the lyre together. Is it the same tension that gives the lyre its sound?
So the expression panta rhei
, "everything flows", is not Heraclitus' own wording. The paraphrase about the river is first found in Plato. But why is it precisely that version that has survived for 2,500 years?
Plato: the shadows on the wall
In the allegory of the cave (Republic, Book VII)
, people sit chained in a cave with their faces to the wall. They see only the shadows of what passes behind them, and believe the shadows are reality. In the Timaeus
(29b), Plato calls the visible world a copy of a model.
If what we see is shadows, how do we know when we are seeing the thing itself? And what if we have measured the shadows very precisely, and then called the measurements reality?
Aristotle: motion
Aristotle begins the seventh book of the Physics
with a sentence that looks simple:
"Everything that is in motion must be moved by something." (Physics VII.1)
He defined motion as the fulfilment of what is possible, precisely while it is still a possibility
( Physics
III.1). 2,300 years later, Werner Heisenberg took up exactly this concept: he called the probability wave in an early quantum theory from 1924 (Bohr, Kramers and Slater) a quantitative version of Aristotle's potentia
, possibility (Physics and Philosophy, 1958, ch. II).
Why did one of the founders of quantum mechanics choose to go back to Aristotle to find words for what he saw?
What they had in common
They lived in India, China and the Greek world, and the cultures barely knew of one another. Even so, many of them arrived at related ideas:
What we see is not the whole of reality.
Nothing stands alone; everything is connected.
For several of them, order and harmony arise from relations, not from things.
For many of them, change is the rule, not the exception.
Was it because the human mind thinks in the same images, wherever it lives? Because they were wrong in the same way? Or because they saw something that was later forgotten?
Next part: From Plotinus to Laplace — how the world became a machine.
Sources
Chāndogya Upanishad 6.13.1–3 (the refrain "tat tvam asi" first appears in 6.8.7).
Laozi, Daodejing
, ch. 1.
Mahāparinibbāna Sutta
, Dīgha Nikāya 16, section 6.7.
Anaximander, transmitted by Simplicius, In Phys.
24.13–25 (DK 12 A9 and B1).
Aristotle, Metaphysics
I.5, 985b23–986a3 (on the Pythagoreans).
Heraclitus, fragment DK 22 B12, B8 (transmitted in Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics
VIII.1, 1155b4) and B51 (Hippolytus, Refutatio
9.9).
Philolaus, fragment DK 44 B6.
Plato, Republic
VII, 514a–517a; Timaeus
29b.
Aristotle, Physics
III.1, 201a10–11, and VII.1.
Werner Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy
(Harper & Brothers, 1958), ch. II.
Part 2: From Plotinus to Laplace — how the world became a machine
The ancient thinkers of India, China and the Greek world saw a world in change, where everything was connected. Two thousand years later, science described the world as clockwork: parts and forces in a space where everything could be measured, timed by a clock that runs the same everywhere.
How did we get there? And what was left behind along the way?
Plotinus: everything flows from the One
Plato's ideas lived on for many hundreds of years after his death. Around 600 years after Plato, in the third century CE, the philosopher Plotinus built on his work. Plotinus wrote about the One
, a ground from which everything flows out, the way light flows from a source. The source is not diminished by radiating outwards. But what radiates out is an image of the source, not the source itself (Enneads V.1.6).
If everything comes from the same source, is the difference between a stone and a thought then a difference in kind, or only in degree?
Ibn al-Haytham: see for yourself
In the eleventh century, Ibn al-Haytham, who worked for much of his life in Cairo, wrote the Book of Optics. He argued, with experiments and geometry, that we see because light comes into
the eye, not because the eye sends out rays. And he tested his claims with experiments.
He also wrote a book of doubts about Ptolemy, the great authority in astronomy. There he says that the seeker after truth is not the one who puts his trust in the writings of the ancients. It is the one who doubts them, tests them and submits to argument and proof, not to what an imperfect human being has said (Doubts Concerning Ptolemy).
What would he have said about accepting a theory because most textbooks do?
Hildegard and Eckhart: the living and the inner
In twelfth-century Germany, Hildegard of Bingen wrote about viriditas
, the green life force that flows through all living things. A century and a half later, Meister Eckhart spoke of how the divine is born in the soul. He was accused of heresy, and several of his statements were condemned by the pope in 1329, the year after his death.
Was it dangerous to say that the greatest thing is found inside the human being? Or was there something else in his statements that the Church could not tolerate?
Nicholas of Cusa: a centre everywhere
In 1440, Nicholas of Cusa wrote On Learned Ignorance. He argued that the world has no fixed centre, and that the earth therefore cannot be at rest in the middle. He took an old image that had been used of God and applied it to the world itself: the world has, so to speak, its centre everywhere and its circumference nowhere (De docta ignorantia, Book II, ch. 12).
If there is no midpoint, what should we measure everything else from?
Giordano Bruno: the price of a vast cosmos
In 1584, Giordano Bruno wrote about an "infinite" universe with countless worlds. On 17 February 1600 he was burned at the stake in the Campo de' Fiori in Rome. The charges were mostly about theology. His view of the cosmos was only one part of the case.
Can anyone be condemned for a view of the cosmos? Or is one condemned for what that view says about power?
Kepler: the harmony of the heavens
Johannes Kepler searched for the music in the movements of the planets. In The Harmony of the World
(1619), he presented his third law: how the time a planet takes to go round the sun is linked to its distance from the sun. For Kepler this was not just a matter of numbers. It was a harmony he believed the Pythagoreans had already sensed.
Did he find the law because he was looking for music, or in spite of it?
Galileo: the book written in mathematics
In Il Saggiatore
("The Assayer", 1623), Galileo Galilei wrote that philosophy is written in the grand book that stands open before our eyes, the universe, and that it is written in the language of mathematics.
Was this where it began, that what could be measured and calculated was what counted? And what happens to what cannot
be measured? Does it become less real, or only less visible?
Descartes: the mind and the machine
René Descartes divided reality in two: the thinking thing ( res cogitans
) and the extended thing ( res extensa
) (Meditations, 1641). Already in the Discours de la méthode
("Discourse on the Method", 1637), he had described animals as machines without minds. The mind was left standing alone, outside the machine.
Ever since, philosophy has struggled with the question he left behind: How can something that has no extension affect something that does? Or was it the division itself that created the problem?
Newton: the laws that explained heaven and earth
In 1687, Isaac Newton's Principia
appeared. With three laws of motion and one law of gravity, he could calculate both a falling body on earth and the orbit of the moon. He described an "absolute" space and an "absolute" time that flows evenly, independent of everything else (Principia, the Scholium after the Definitions).
But Newton did not know what caused gravity, and he said so himself. In a letter to Richard Bentley in 1693, he wrote that the idea of a gravity that is innate and essential to matter, so that one body may act upon another at a distance through a vacuum without anything in between, was to him so great an absurdity that he believed no one who could think clearly about such questions would ever fall into it. Gravity must have a cause, he wrote, but whether it was material or not, he left to his readers to consider.
What happened to Newton's own doubt when his successors turned his law into a picture of the whole of reality?
Leibniz: space is relations
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz objected. In his correspondence with Samuel Clarke (1715–16), who defended Newton's view, he argued that space is not a container but something purely relative: an order of things that exist at the same time
, just as time is an order of what follows one after another.
Leibniz also mocked Newton's God, who in his view needed to wind up his watch from time to time so that it would not stop (Leibniz's first letter, 1715). The correspondence ended when Leibniz died in November 1716. Who was right? And was the question ever settled?
Laplace: the clockwork completed
In 1814, Pierre-Simon Laplace took the idea as far as it could go. He imagined an intelligence that knew all the forces and the position of everything in nature. For it, nothing would be uncertain: the future and the past would lie open before it (Philosophical Essay on Probabilities).
Had the world become a machine? And what then became of Aristotle's idea that motion is the possible becoming real?
What was gained, and what was left behind
What was gained we see every day: measurements, calculations and machines that work. What was left behind are the questions that did not fit in:
What is it that acts between
things? (Newton asked.)
Are space and time something in themselves, or relations? (Leibniz asked.)
Where does the mind belong in a machine? (Descartes left the question behind.)
Were the questions answered, or only forgotten because the calculations came out right?
Next part: Faraday, Maxwell and what fills the space between things.
Sources
Plotinus, Enneads
V.1.6.
Ibn al-Haytham, Kitāb al-Manāẓir
(Book of Optics), c. 1011–1021 (the dating is disputed; El-Bizri suggests 1028–1038); al-Shukūk ʿalā Baṭlamyūs
(Doubts Concerning Ptolemy).
Hildegard of Bingen, on viriditas
in, among others, Scivias
(completed 1151/52).
Pope John XXII, the bull In agro dominico
(27 March 1329), against Meister Eckhart.
Nicholas of Cusa, De docta ignorantia
(1440), Book II, ch. 11–12.
Giordano Bruno, De l'infinito, universo e mondi
(1584); executed in Rome on 17 February 1600.
Johannes Kepler, Harmonices Mundi
(1619), Book V.
Galileo Galilei, Il Saggiatore
(1623).
René Descartes, Discours de la méthode
(1637), Part V; Meditationes de prima philosophia
(1641), Meditation VI.
Isaac Newton, Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica
(1687), Scholium after the Definitions; letter to Richard Bentley, 25 February 1692/93.
G. W. Leibniz and Samuel Clarke, the correspondence 1715–1716 (Leibniz's first letter and third letter, § 4).
Pierre-Simon Laplace, Essai philosophique sur les probabilités
(1814).
Part 3: From Ørsted to Einstein — what fills the space between things?
Newton called it an absurdity that gravity should be innate in matter itself, so that one body may act upon another through a vacuum, without anything in between. Leibniz held that space is not a container, but relations between things. Around a hundred years later the question came back, now from the laboratory.
Is the space between things empty? Or is it filled with something we have not yet seen?
Ørsted: the needle that moved
In 1820, Hans Christian Ørsted, professor at the University of Copenhagen, noticed that a compass needle moved when he switched on a current in a wire nearby. On 21 July that year he sent out a four-page paper, in Latin, to physicists and scientific societies. An electric current produced a magnetic force.
A small needle showed that electricity and magnetism were connected. How many other divisions in nature are only divisions in our own books?
Faraday: the lines in space
Michael Faraday was born in 1791, the son of a blacksmith. He said himself that his schooling was little more than the rudiments of reading, writing and arithmetic. At fourteen he was apprenticed to a bookbinder. In 1813 he became a laboratory assistant to Humphry Davy at the Royal Institution in London.
On 29 August 1831 he wound copper wire in coils on opposite sides of an iron ring. When he switched on the current in the coils on one side, a brief pulse of current ran through the coils on the other: electromagnetic induction.
Faraday imagined lines of force
around magnets and currents. Iron filings around a magnet show the path of the lines. But are the lines only a picture we draw? Or is something there, even when no one scatters filings?
Faraday: a question, not an answer
In April 1846, at the end of a Friday evening lecture, Faraday put forward an idea that he afterwards wrote down in a letter: "Thoughts on Ray-vibrations". Could the vibrations that, in one theory, were supposed to account for radiation take place in the very lines of force that connect particles and bodies together? Then one could dispense with the ether, the invisible medium in which the vibrations were otherwise supposed to take place. But Faraday stressed that these were only the "vague impressions" of his own mind, thrown out as matter for speculation.
In 1852 he wrote of the lines of force: "I incline to the opinion that they have a physical existence correspondent to that of their analogue, the electric lines …" He added that he held the opinion "with some hesitation", and that such speculations should always be held as doubtful, and liable to error and to change.
What happens to an idea that is put forward as a question, but remembered as an answer?
Maxwell: the lines get equations
James Clerk Maxwell was born in Edinburgh in 1831, the same year Faraday discovered induction. In 1855–56 he wrote "On Faraday's Lines of Force", in which he put Faraday's lines of force into mathematical form. Faraday replied in a letter of 25 March 1857 that he was at first "almost frightened" when he saw so much mathematical force brought to bear on the subject, and then surprised to see how well the subject stood it.
In 1861–62 Maxwell calculated how fast waves would travel in a model of the medium, and came very close to the measured speed of light. In 1865 came "A Dynamical Theory of the Electromagnetic Field". There he explains, in his own words, the name he chose:
"The theory I propose may therefore be called a theory of the Electromagnetic Field, because it has to do with the space in the neighbourhood of the electric or magnetic bodies." (Maxwell 1865, section 3)
Further on he writes that the agreement of the results seems to show that light and magnetism are states of the same substance, and that light is an electromagnetic disturbance propagated through the field according to electromagnetic laws (section 97).
In 1873 Maxwell wrote that where the mathematicians saw forces acting at a distance, Faraday saw lines of force traversing all space:
"Faraday saw a medium where they saw nothing but distance." (A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism, 1873, Preface)
And he added that Faraday's way of thinking was also a mathematical one, even though it was not written in the conventional form of mathematical symbols. Did Faraday lack mathematics? Or did he have it in a different form?
Hertz: the waves that could be caught
Maxwell's theory said there had to be electromagnetic waves that no one had yet detected. In Karlsruhe, in the years 1886–1888, Heinrich Hertz succeeded in producing them and picking them up. He showed that they can be reflected, refracted and polarised, as light can, and that their speed is in line with that of light. His work opened the way for radio and wireless communication.
Later Hertz wrote, in short, that Maxwell's theory is
Maxwell's equations. But is a theory only its equations? Or is it also the picture of what goes on in the space between things?
The ether: an ocean no one found
Maxwell, too, assumed a medium. In 1865 he wrote that light and heat gave some reason to believe that there is an ethereal medium filling space and permeating bodies. Surely waves must wave in something
?
In 1887, in the basement of a student residence in Cleveland in the United States, Albert A. Michelson and Edward W. Morley set out to use light to detect the earth's motion through the ether. The shift they measured was "certainly less than the twentieth part" of what they expected. Their conclusion was cautious: the velocity of the earth relative to the ether was probably less than one sixth of the earth's velocity around the sun, and certainly less than one fourth.
If you look for something and do not find it, does that mean it is not there? Or that you have been looking for the wrong kind of thing?
Einstein: the ether goes, the field stays
On 30 June 1905, a manuscript from Albert Einstein reached the journal Annalen der Physik
: "On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies". He referred to the unsuccessful attempts to discover any motion of the earth relative to the "light medium", without naming any particular experiment. The introduction of a "luminiferous ether", he wrote, would prove to be "superfluous", because his theory did not require an "absolutely stationary space".
In a lecture in Leiden in 1920, Einstein described one conclusion that could be drawn: that the ether does not exist, and that the electromagnetic fields are not states of a medium, but independent realities. Then he added that the special theory of relativity nevertheless does not compel us to reject the ether. And of the general theory he said:
"According to the general theory of relativity space without ether is unthinkable." (Einstein, Äther und Relativitätstheorie, 1920, translated by G. B. Jeffery and W. Perrett)
Without it, light could not travel, and there could be no measuring-rods and clocks. But this ether could not be thought of as having the quality characteristic of matter that can be weighed: consisting of parts that can be tracked through time. The idea of motion could not be applied to it.
Was the ether removed, or was the word given a new meaning? And what is the difference between an empty space and a space that itself has properties?
What was found, and what was left open
What was found is the basis for the radio waves Hertz caught, and for understanding light as electromagnetic waves. What was left open are the questions:
Are the lines of force something real, or only a picture? (Faraday leaned towards the first, but with hesitation.)
Can a wave exist without something that waves? (Maxwell assumed a medium.)
Is space empty, or does it have properties of its own? (Einstein took the question up again in 1920.)
In 1865, 172 years after Newton's letter to Bentley, physics had gained a theory of what lies in between: the field. But do we know what a field is
? Or do we only know how it behaves?
Next part: The quantum pioneers and the smallest of all.
Sources
H. C. Ørsted, Experimenta circa effectum conflictus electrici in acum magneticam
(21 July 1820).
Michael Faraday, the induction experiment with the iron ring, 29 August 1831; schooling, apprenticeship and appointment at the Royal Institution according to the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography
, the entry "Faraday, Michael".
Michael Faraday, "Thoughts on Ray-vibrations", letter to Richard Phillips dated 15 April 1846, Philosophical Magazine
, ser. 3, vol. 28, no. 188 (May 1846); also in Experimental Researches in Electricity
, vol. III, pp. 447–452.
Michael Faraday, "On the Physical Character of the Lines of Magnetic Force", Philosophical Magazine
, ser. 4, vol. 3 (June 1852), paragraphs 3244, 3269 and 3299.
Michael Faraday, letter to J. C. Maxwell, 25 March 1857 (Cambridge University Library, Add MS 7655/II/6).
J. C. Maxwell, "On Faraday's Lines of Force", Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society
10, pp. 27–83 (read to the Society 1855–56).
J. C. Maxwell, "On Physical Lines of Force", Philosophical Magazine
(1861–1862).
J. C. Maxwell, "A Dynamical Theory of the Electromagnetic Field", Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London
155 (1865), pp. 459 ff., sections 3, 4 and 97 (received 27 October 1864, read 8 December 1864).
J. C. Maxwell, A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism
(1873), vol. I, Preface (dated 1 February 1873).
Heinrich Hertz, the experiments at the Technische Hochschule Karlsruhe 1886–1888; Electric Waves
(1893), Introduction.
A. A. Michelson and E. W. Morley, "On the Relative Motion of the Earth and the Luminiferous Ether", American Journal of Science
, ser. 3, vol. 34, no. 203 (November 1887), pp. 333–345.
Albert Einstein, "Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper", Annalen der Physik
, 4th series, vol. 17 (1905), pp. 891 ff. (received 30 June 1905).
Albert Einstein, Äther und Relativitätstheorie
, lecture at the University of Leiden (Berlin: Julius Springer, 1920; printed with the inscription "Rede gehalten am 5. Mai 1920 an der Reichs-Universität zu Leiden"); English translation by G. B. Jeffery and W. Perrett, "Ether and the Theory of Relativity", in Sidelights on Relativity
(London: Methuen, 1922).